Consider the following argument: Marcia's primary leadership trait is her ability to give commands because if all else fails, she can always be an effective leader by directing others. Which of the following, if True, would undermine this argument?
A) Marcia has the ability to give clear direction in uncertain circumstances.
B) Marcia relies on her experience in order to know the right thing to do when a decision needs to be made.
C) Marcia has been known to be firm and decisive when dealing with problem employees.
D) Marcia is well-respected by her colleagues in the organization.
E) In almost all cases, Marcia's decisions are backed up by her superiors.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

B) This answer choice would suggest that Marcia would not be able to exercise her decisiveness without her broad knowledge base that allows her to make firm decisions. In that case, the ability to give commands is not in itself her primary leadership trait. Choices A and C would lend support to the given argument. Choices D and E neither support nor undermine the argument.

Consider the Following Argument: Marcia's Primary Leadership Trait Is Her