Examination of Euthyphro's second proposal, that the pious is what the gods love, reveals
A) that Euthyphro's stories about the gods lead him, together with this definition, into contradiction.
B) that there are gods who don't agree.
C) that we don't know what the gods love.
D) that it only tells us how the gods regard the pious, not what it is.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Euthyphro's stories about the gods suggest that they often disagree, leading to contradictions when trying to define piety as what all gods love.

Examination of Euthyphro's Second Proposal, That the Pious Is What