Which of the following best captures the process of evaluating an argument by analogy?
A) Consider all of the relevant similarities to determine whether they are strong enough to establish the argument's conclusion.
B) Brainstorm every possible similarity between the two actions to determine whether there are enough to outweigh the differences.
C) Count the number of similarities and differences to see whether the actions are more similar or more different.
D) Consider all of the relevant similarities and differences between the two actions to determine whether the similarities outweigh the differences.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Evaluating an argument by analogy involves considering both the similarities and differences between the two actions or situations being compared. The strength of the analogy depends on whether the relevant similarities are significant enough to support the conclusion, despite any differences. This process is more nuanced than simply counting similarities and differences or focusing only on similarities.

Which of the Following Best Captures the Process of Evaluating