What would be the difference in the tax consequences of an $18,000 withdrawal from a Roth IRA versus a traditional IRA if $15,000 represents long-term capital gains,$2,000 is short-term capital gains,and $1,000 is interest? Assume a tax rate of 30% and a capital gains tax rate of 10%.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

With a Roth IRA, the withdrawal of $18,000 would not be subject to any taxes since the contributions were made after-tax. However, with a traditional IRA, the entire $18,000 would be subject to income tax at 30%, resulting in $5,400 in taxes. Additionally, the $15,000 of long-term capital gains and $2,000 of short-term capital gains would be subject to a separate 10% capital gains tax, resulting in an additional $1,700 in taxes. Therefore, the total tax liability with a traditional IRA would be $7,100, which is $5,400 more in taxes than with a Roth IRA.

What Would Be the Difference in the Tax Consequences of an $18,000