Reconstruct the following as a standard-form syllogism;then,determine whether it is valid using either a Venn diagram or the rules of the syllogism.
"Not necessarily,Mr.Dalgliesh.Suppose it's a double bluff.Suppose he's saying in effect,'Look,I can prove I knew the Whistler was dead.Whoever killed Hilary Robarts didn't know.So why aren't you looking for someone who hadn't been told that the Whistler's body had been found?'" -P.D.James,Devices and Desires
I = people identical to me;W = people who knew the Whistler was dead;K = people who killed Hilary Robarts.
No W are K.
All I are W.
Therefore,no I are K.
Valid.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer of Reconstruct the following as a standard-form syllogism;then,determine whether it is valid using either a Venn diagram or the rules of the syllogism.
"Not necessarily,Mr.Dalgliesh.Suppose it's a double bluff.Suppose he's saying in effect,'Look,I can prove I knew the Whistler was dead.Whoever killed Hilary Robarts didn't know.So why aren't you looking for someone who hadn't been told that the Whistler's body had been found?'" -P.D.James,Devices and Desires
I = people identical to me;W = people who knew the Whistler was dead;K = people who killed Hilary Robarts.
No W are K.
All I are W.
Therefore,no I are K.
Valid.

Reconstruct the Following as a Standard-Form Syllogism;then,determine Whether It Is