In order to arrive at a verdict, juries are supposed to:
A) use an algorithm to make sure that the decision produces a just result.
B) engage in dialectical reasoning for and against the defendant's guilt.
C) make sure all the premises have been supplied by the attorneys.
D) use deductive reasoning so the verdict necessarily follows from the evidence.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Juries are supposed to engage in dialectical reasoning, considering arguments for and against the defendant's guilt. This allows the jury to carefully consider the evidence and make a well-informed decision. While deductive reasoning can also be used in the process, it is not enough on its own to arrive at a verdict, as it relies on the initial premises being true. Algorithms may be useful in certain aspects of the legal system, but they cannot replace the nuanced decision-making process required of a jury. Finally, it is the job of the attorneys to present evidence and arguments, not the jury's job to ensure that all premises have been supplied.

In Order to Arrive at a Verdict, Juries Are Supposed