Consider this comment from the philosopher C.D.Broad regarding Kant's means-end principle: "If we isolate a man who is a carrier of typhoid,we are treating him merely as a cause of infection to others.But,if we refuse to isolate him,we are treating other people merely as means to his comfort and culture." This example suggests that:
A)our duties not to use people merely as a means can conflict,and Kant provides no counsel on how to resolve such dilemmas.
B)our duties not to use people merely as a means can sometimes be difficult to discern,but they never actually conflict.
C)our duties not to use people merely as a means are imperfect duties.
D)our duties are always clear upon further reflection.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The example shows how the principle of not using people merely as a means can conflict with itself in certain situations. Kant does not provide a clear solution to such conflicts, resulting in difficulty in resolving moral dilemmas that arise from conflicting duties. Therefore, option A is the best choice.

Consider This Comment from the Philosopher C