What is the significance of the case of R.v.McIntosh and McCarthy (1997)?
A)It dealt with racial segregation.
B)It raises potential problems with the Mohan criteria.
C)It dealt with issues associated with the insanity defence.
D)It highlighted the importance of voluntary (i.e.,non-coercive)confessions.
E)It established guidelines for cross-examination.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The case of R.v.McIntosh and McCarthy (1997) raised potential problems with the Mohan criteria, which are used to determine the admissibility of expert testimony in Canadian courts. The court expressed concerns that the criteria were too rigid and did not take into account the nuances of different types of expert evidence. This has led to ongoing debates about the appropriateness of the Mohan criteria and the need for more flexible standards.

What Is the Significance of the Case of R