X a surgeon, amputates the right hand index finger of Y a 14 year old beggar, with Y's consent, and in good faith that this would enable Y to get more alms. In this case
A)X commits no offence as the act was done with the consent of Y
B)X commits an offence as the consent of a child of 14 years is of no avail
C)X commits no offence as the act was done in good faith for the benefit and with the consent of Y
D)X is not exempted from criminal liability as the act done was not in good faith within the meaning of Indian Penal Code.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer of X a surgeon, amputates the right hand index finger of Y a 14 year old beggar, with Y's consent, and in good faith that this would enable Y to get more alms. In this case
A)X commits no offence as the act was done with the consent of Y
B)X commits an offence as the consent of a child of 14 years is of no avail
C)X commits no offence as the act was done in good faith for the benefit and with the consent of Y
D)X is not exempted from criminal liability as the act done was not in good faith within the meaning of Indian Penal Code.

X a Surgeon, Amputates the Right Hand Index Finger of Y