Which is the best counterexample to the principle in the following Argument from Principle?
[Pay attention to the criteria for good counterexamples from Chapter 6 of Doing Practical Ethics.]
1) If animals do something, then it's permissible for humans to do it.
2) Animals eat other animals.
So, it's permissible for humans to eat animals.
A) Animals don't use computers, but it's permissible for humans to do so.
B) Not all animals eat other animals. Herbivores, for instance, only eat plants.
C) Animals protect their young from threats, and it's clearly permissible for humans to do that, too.
D) Animals kill their competitors in order to order to maintain power in their group, but that's clearly not moral for humans to do.

Question

Which is the best counterexample to the principle in the following Argument from Principle?
[Pay attention to the criteria for good counterexamples from Chapter 6 of Doing Practical Ethics.]
 1) If animals do something, then it's permissible for humans to do it.
2) Animals eat other animals.
So, it's permissible for humans to eat animals.
A) Animals don't use computers, but it's permissible for humans to do so. 
B) Not all animals eat other animals. Herbivores, for instance, only eat plants. 
C) Animals protect their young from threats, and it's clearly permissible for humans to do that, too. 
D) Animals kill their competitors in order to order to maintain power in their group, but that's clearly not moral for humans to do.

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer of Which is the best counterexample to the principle in the following Argument from Principle?
[Pay attention to the criteria for good counterexamples from Chapter 6 of Doing Practical Ethics.]
 1) If animals do something, then it's permissible for humans to do it.
2) Animals eat other animals.
So, it's permissible for humans to eat animals.
A) Animals don't use computers, but it's permissible for humans to do so. 
B) Not all animals eat other animals. Herbivores, for instance, only eat plants. 
C) Animals protect their young from threats, and it's clearly permissible for humans to do that, too. 
D) Animals kill their competitors in order to order to maintain power in their group, but that's clearly not moral for humans to do.

Which Is the Best Counterexample to the Principle in the Following