According to Ross, in determining which prima facie duty is the most "stringent" in some particular
Case and thus represents one's all-things-considered duty, one must
A) appeal to a set of fixed rules to calculate which duty will prevail.
B) appeal to a moral authority.
C) use one's judgment rather than appealing to a fixed set of rules.
D) perform a utilitarian calculation.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

According to Ross, determining which prima facie duty is most important in a specific case requires judgment rather than relying on fixed rules or calculations. Ross believed that moral decision-making was not reducible to a set of rules, so determinations of one's all-things-considered duty require a nuanced and reflective approach. Therefore, option C, using one's judgment rather than appealing to a fixed set of rules, is the best choice.

According to Ross, in Determining Which Prima Facie Duty Is