According to Thomson, "If anyone does wish to deduce 'he has a right' from 'you ought,' then all the same he must surely grant that there are cases in which it is not morally required of you that you allow that violinist to use your kidneys, and in which he does not have a right to use them, and in which you do not do him an injustice if you refuse."

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Thomson argues that just because someone says "you ought" to do something, it does not necessarily mean that the other person has a right to demand or use your resources. There may be situations where you are not morally required to comply and refusing to do so does not constitute an injustice.

According to Thomson, "If Anyone Does Wish to Deduce 'He