A key premise in the Benefits Argument is:
A) If a practice is morally legitimate, it violates no one's rights.
B) If a practice is morally legitimate, it provides great benefits to many people.
C) If a practice provides great benefits to many people and harms very few, then it is morally legitimate.
D) If a practice provides great benefits to many people and violates no one's rights, then it is morally legitimate.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Benefits Argument states that a practice is morally legitimate if it provides great benefits to many people and violates no one's rights. This means that a practice can be considered morally right if it has a positive impact on society and does not infringe on anyone's rights. Choice A is not a key premise in the Benefits Argument, as there are practices that may be morally legitimate even if they do violate someone's rights. Choice B is also not a key premise, as providing great benefits does not necessarily make a practice morally legitimate if it violates someone's rights. Choice C is partly correct, but it is not enough for a practice to simply harm very few people; it must also not violate anyone's rights to be considered morally legitimate.

A Key Premise in the Benefits Argument Is