What problem does Socrates's question in the Euthyphro raise for the Divine Command Theory?
A) If God does not exist, the Divine Command Theory must be false.
B) Many people don't believe in God but still behave morally.
C) If the Divine Command Theory is true, then God's commands are arbitrary.
D) If the Divine Command Theory is true, then it is impossible to know what is right or wrong.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Socrates's question in the Euthyphro raises the problem for the Divine Command Theory that if moral values or obligations are based solely on God's commands, then they become arbitrary. If God's commands are arbitrary and could have been different, then morality becomes a matter of God's whim rather than a matter of reason or intrinsic value. This undermines the idea that morality is objective and meaningful, which is a significant challenge for the Divine Command Theory.

What Problem Does Socrates's Question in the Euthyphro Raise for the Divine