Which of the following claims is the desire satisfaction theorist unable to endorse?
A) Health, wealth, and happiness are often instrumentally good for us.
B) Some desires are intrinsically better than others.
C) What is good for us is up to us.
D) Some desires are disinterested.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The desire satisfaction theorist holds that something is good for us if and only if it satisfies our desires, regardless of whether those desires are intrinsically or instrumentally valuable. However, if the claim is that some desires are intrinsically better than others, this suggests that there are some desires that are more valuable in themselves, and not just as means to other ends. This goes against the desire satisfaction theorist's view that the value of something is entirely dependent on its ability to satisfy desires.

Which of the Following Claims Is the Desire Satisfaction Theorist