Which of the following best captures Singer's response to the objection that overseas aid should be the government's responsibility and giving privately to charities allows the government and noncontributing citizens to shirk their obligations?
A) Singer argues that unless there is definite proof that not giving privately brings about more governmental aid, refusing to contribute to famine relief would be refusing to prevent a lot of suffering.
B) Singer argues that there is no difference between government contributions and charity contributions because both are social institutions meant to relieve suffering caused by famine.
C) Singer argues that rather than contributing to private charities, people should run for government office so that they can directly change governmental policy when it comes to famine relief.
D) Singer argues that charities can lobby governments to provide more famine relief and charities have the best expertise to contribute advice on these issues.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Singer's argument is that the potential for government and non-contributors to shirk their responsibilities does not justify an individual's decision not to give to famine relief, unless it can be shown that withholding private contributions would indeed lead to increased government aid. His focus is on the immediate prevention of suffering rather than the potential for changing government policy through withholding private aid.

Which of the Following Best Captures Singer's Response to the Objection