Consider the example of contradictory fundamental beliefs, in the paragraph that begins "The third benefit which the study of philosophy can confer…" Explain why belief in free will conflicts with belief in causal laws of nature. Can you resolve the apparent conflict? If so, explain how. If not, explain why not.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer is The belief in free will conflicts with the belief in causal laws of nature because free will suggests that individuals have the ability to make choices and decisions that are not determined by prior causes, while causal laws of nature suggest that every event is caused by preceding events in a deterministic manner. This apparent conflict arises from the tension between the idea of personal agency and the idea of a deterministic universe governed by causal laws.

One possible resolution to this conflict is to consider the concept of compatibilism, which argues that free will and determinism are actually compatible. Proponents of compatibilism argue that even if our actions are determined by prior causes, as long as we are able to act in accordance with our own desires and intentions, we can still be considered to have free will. In this view, free will is not necessarily incompatible with causal laws of nature, as long as we understand free will in a way that is consistent with determinism.

Another potential resolution is to reconsider our understanding of causal laws of nature. While these laws may describe the regularities and patterns in the natural world, they may not necessarily preclude the existence of free will. It is possible that our understanding of causality is limited and that there may be room for agency and choice within the framework of causal laws.

Ultimately, whether or not the apparent conflict between free will and causal laws of nature can be resolved depends on one's philosophical perspective and interpretation of these concepts. Some may find compatibilism or a reevaluation of causal laws to be convincing resolutions, while others may continue to see an inherent tension between these fundamental beliefs.

Consider the Example of Contradictory Fundamental Beliefs, in the Paragraph