One objection to identity theory is that if mental states are identical with brain states, then
A)they should not be able to interact, which they can.
B)our physical descriptions of behavior are inaccurate.
C)they should both have the same properties, which they don't.
D)mentalistic language should be replaced.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

If mental states and brain states are identical, they should have the same properties. However, mental states are typically characterized by their subjective, first-person qualities (e.g. the experience of pain), while brain states are typically characterized in objective, third-person terms (e.g. electrochemical activity in a particular region of the brain). This mismatch in properties presents a significant challenge for identity theory.

One Objection to Identity Theory Is That If Mental States