Which situation is an appropriate application of the doctrine of stare decisis?
A)A reference to a dissenting opinion in the highest court in the same state with the same or similar facts.
B)A reference to a majority opinion in the highest court in the same state with the same or similar facts.
C)A reference to a statute in an appropriate state covering the same or similar facts.
D)A reference to a majority opinion in the highest court in a neighboring state with the same or similar facts.

Question

Which situation is an appropriate application of the doctrine of stare decisis?​
A)A reference to a dissenting opinion in the highest court in the same state with the same or similar facts.
B)A reference to a majority opinion in the highest court in the same state with the same or similar facts.
C)A reference to a statute in an appropriate state covering the same or similar facts.
D)A reference to a majority opinion in the highest court in a neighboring state with the same or similar facts.

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Stare decisis is a legal principle that obligates courts to follow the precedents set by previous decisions. Choice B is correct because it involves applying the majority opinion from the highest court in the same state, which is exactly how stare decisis works. Courts look to past decisions of higher courts within the same jurisdiction for guidance on how to rule on similar cases.

Which Situation Is an Appropriate Application of the Doctrine of Stare