Someone might say to Marquis, "Your view that a future like ours is what matters is too narrow. Why should a creature's future have to be like ours in order for it to be wrong to kill the creature? Why isn't it important enough that the creature have a future of its own? How could Marquis respond to that argument? Do you find his perspective on this issue ultimately convincing or not? Explain your answer with specific examples.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer of Someone might say to Marquis, "Your view that a future like ours is what matters is too narrow. Why should a creature's future have to be like ours in order for it to be wrong to kill the creature? Why isn't it important enough that the creature have a future of its own? How could Marquis respond to that argument? Do you find his perspective on this issue ultimately convincing or not? Explain your answer with specific examples.

Someone Might Say to Marquis, "Your View That a Future