Common carriers are practically insurers for the goods they carry. Consolidated Shipping is a common carrier and is transporting two new ferry guidance systems to Singapore. During the shipping, both were damaged by corrosion. It was determined that the cause was "inadequate packaging". Is the carrier liable for these damages?
A) No, because this is inherent vice.
B) Yes, since this is not an act of God nor act of war.
C) No, because both parties were aware of the poor packaging.
D) Yes, since this is not an available defence for common carriers.
E) No, since a standard exemption clause would protect it.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Inherent vice refers to a defect or characteristic in the nature of the goods themselves that causes them to deteriorate or be damaged. In this case, inadequate packaging leading to corrosion is considered an inherent vice, which is a common defense for carriers against liability.

Common Carriers Are Practically Insurers for the Goods They Carry