"When we were discussing thermodynamics the other day, Dave didn't say anything. That must mean he doesn't know anything about the topic." What would be the most useful question to debunk this claim?
A) Does Dave have a degree in science?
B) Could there be another reason why Dave remained quiet?
C) How long has Dave been working at our company?
D) Is Dave known for his critical thinking skills?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

There could be various reasons why Dave remained quiet during the discussion. Perhaps he was already familiar with the topic and chose not to speak or he was still processing the information. Asking this question would help avoid making assumptions and jumping to conclusions about Dave's knowledge on the topic. The other options are not relevant to the situation and do not help in debunking the claim.

"When We Were Discussing Thermodynamics the Other Day, Dave Didn't