The main point of the thought experiment in which Smith drowns his cousin and Jones watches his cousin drown is that
A) passive euthanasia is just as morally wrong as active euthanasia.
B) there is no relevant difference between killing and letting die.
C) killing is morally wrong but letting die is morally permissible.
D) None of the above

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The thought experiment presented by Smith and Jones highlights the notion that in some cases, there may not be a fundamental moral difference between letting someone die and actively killing someone. In both cases, the outcome is the same – the individual in question dies. Smith's act of drowning his cousin and Jones' act of letting his cousin drown both lead to the same result, showing that there may not be an inherent moral difference between the two actions. This view is supported by proponents of the ethic of care and other moral theories that argue against a strict distinction between acts of commission and acts of omission.

The Main Point of the Thought Experiment in Which Smith