Which criteria are used to judge a qualitative study's scientific rigor? (Select all that apply.)
A) Reality based
B) Credibility
C) Confidentiality of participants
D) Auditability
E) Recordkeeping
F) Fittingness

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Scientific rigor refers to the systematic and thorough approach taken by researchers to ensure the quality and credibility of their qualitative study. The following criteria are commonly used to assess the scientific rigor of a qualitative study:
A) Reality based: This criterion is not commonly used to judge the scientific rigor of a qualitative study.
B) Credibility: This criterion refers to the degree to which the findings accurately reflect the experiences and perspectives of the participants. It can be enhanced through methods such as member checking, peer debriefing, and prolonged engagement with the data. Therefore, it is an essential criterion to judge the scientific rigor of a qualitative study.
C) Confidentiality of participants: This criterion refers to the protection of participants' identities and personal information. While it is important to maintain confidentiality, it is not commonly used to judge the scientific rigor of a qualitative study.
D) Auditability: This criterion refers to the extent to which the research methods and findings can be audited and traced back to the data. It can be enhanced through methods such as an audit trail and thick description of the research process. Therefore, it is an essential criterion to judge the scientific rigor of a qualitative study.
E) Recordkeeping: This criterion refers to the researcher's ability to keep accurate and detailed records of the research process. While it is important to maintain good recordkeeping, it is not commonly used to judge the scientific rigor of a qualitative study.
F) Fittingness: This criterion refers to the degree to which the findings are relevant and useful to the research question and the broader field of study. It can be enhanced through methods such as reflexivity and theoretical saturation. Therefore, it is an essential criterion to judge the scientific rigor of a qualitative study.
In summary, the most appropriate criteria to judge the scientific rigor of a qualitative study are B, D, and F.

Which Criteria Are Used to Judge a Qualitative Study's Scientific