expand icon
book Introductory Econometrics: A Modern Approach 6th Edition by Jeffrey M Wooldridge cover

Introductory Econometrics: A Modern Approach 6th Edition by Jeffrey M Wooldridge

Edition 6ISBN: 130527010X
book Introductory Econometrics: A Modern Approach 6th Edition by Jeffrey M Wooldridge cover

Introductory Econometrics: A Modern Approach 6th Edition by Jeffrey M Wooldridge

Edition 6ISBN: 130527010X
Exercise 22

Consider a simple time series model where the explanatory variable has classical measurement error:

yt = ?0 + ?1xt* + ut

xt = xt* + et,

where ut has zero mean and is uncorrelated with xt* and et. We observe yt and xt only. Assume that et has zero mean and is uncorrelated with xt* and that xt* also has a zero mean (this last assumption is only to simplify the algebra).

(i) Write xt* = xt — et and plug this into  Consider a simple time series model where the explanatory variable has classical measurement error: y<span class=sub>t</span> = ?<span class=sub>0</span> + ?<span class=sub>1</span>x<span class=sub>t</span><span class=sup>*</span> + u<span class=sub>t</span> x<span class=sub>t</span> = x<span class=sub>t</span><span class=sup>*</span> + e<span class=sub>t</span>, where u<span class=sub>t</span> has zero mean and is uncorrelated with x<span class=sub>t</span><span class=sup>*</span> and e<span class=sub>t</span>. We observe y<span class=sub>t</span> and x<span class=sub>t</span> only. Assume that e<span class=sub>t</span> has zero mean and is uncorrelated with x<span class=sub>t</span><span class=sup>*</span> and that x<span class=sub>t</span><span class=sup>*</span> also has a zero mean (this last assumption is only to simplify the algebra). <blockquote> (i) Write x<span class=sub>t</span><span class=sup>*</span> = x<span class=sub>t</span> — e<span class=sub>t</span> and plug this into   . Show that the error term in the new equation, say, ?<span class=sub>t</span>, is negatively correlated with x<span class=sub>t</span> if ?<span class=sub>1</span> > 0. What does this imply about the OLS estimator of ?<span class=sub>1</span> from the regression of y<span class=sub>t</span> on x<span class=sub>t</span>? (ii) In addition to the previous assumptions, assume that u and e are uncorrelated with all past values of x<span class=sub>t</span><span class=sup>*</span> and e<span class=sub>t</span>; in particular, with x<span class=sub>t-1</span><span class=sup>*</span> and e<span class=sub>t-1</span>. Show that E(x<span class=sub>t-1</span>v<span class=sub>t</span>) = 0, where v<span class=sub>t</span> is the error term in the model from part (i). (iii) Are x<span class=sub>t</span> and x<span class=sub>t-1</span> likely to be correlated? Explain. (iv) What do parts (ii) and (iii) suggest as a useful strategy for consistently estimating ?<span class=sub>0</span> and ?<span class=sub>1</span>? </blockquote>   . Show that the error term in the new equation, say, ?t, is negatively correlated with xt if ?1 > 0. What does this imply about the OLS estimator of ?1 from the regression of yt on xt?

(ii) In addition to the previous assumptions, assume that u and e are uncorrelated with all past values of xt* and et; in particular, with xt-1* and et-1. Show that E(xt-1vt) = 0, where vt is the error term in the model from part (i).

(iii) Are xt and xt-1 likely to be correlated? Explain.

(iv) What do parts (ii) and (iii) suggest as a useful strategy for consistently estimating

?0 and ?1?

Step-by-step solution
Verified
like image
like image

Step 1 of 4

(i). When    <div class=answer> (i). When   is plugged into   <i> </i> <i>   </i>   Where,   Given that   is uncorrelated with   and   ,   is uncorrelated with   . Since   is uncorrelated with   , <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i>   When,   . Since the covariance of explanatory variable and error term is negative, OLS estimator <i>ß</i><sub>1</sub> will have a downward effect. is plugged into    <div class=answer> (i). When   is plugged into   <i> </i> <i>   </i>   Where,   Given that   is uncorrelated with   and   ,   is uncorrelated with   . Since   is uncorrelated with   , <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i>   When,   . Since the covariance of explanatory variable and error term is negative, OLS estimator <i>ß</i><sub>1</sub> will have a downward effect.

    <div class=answer> (i). When   is plugged into   <i> </i> <i>   </i>   Where,   Given that   is uncorrelated with   and   ,   is uncorrelated with   . Since   is uncorrelated with   , <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i>   When,   . Since the covariance of explanatory variable and error term is negative, OLS estimator <i>ß</i><sub>1</sub> will have a downward effect.

    <div class=answer> (i). When   is plugged into   <i> </i> <i>   </i>   Where,   Given that   is uncorrelated with   and   ,   is uncorrelated with   . Since   is uncorrelated with   , <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i>   When,   . Since the covariance of explanatory variable and error term is negative, OLS estimator <i>ß</i><sub>1</sub> will have a downward effect.

Where,

    <div class=answer> (i). When   is plugged into   <i> </i> <i>   </i>   Where,   Given that   is uncorrelated with   and   ,   is uncorrelated with   . Since   is uncorrelated with   , <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i>   When,   . Since the covariance of explanatory variable and error term is negative, OLS estimator <i>ß</i><sub>1</sub> will have a downward effect.

Given that    <div class=answer> (i). When   is plugged into   <i> </i> <i>   </i>   Where,   Given that   is uncorrelated with   and   ,   is uncorrelated with   . Since   is uncorrelated with   , <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i>   When,   . Since the covariance of explanatory variable and error term is negative, OLS estimator <i>ß</i><sub>1</sub> will have a downward effect. is uncorrelated with    <div class=answer> (i). When   is plugged into   <i> </i> <i>   </i>   Where,   Given that   is uncorrelated with   and   ,   is uncorrelated with   . Since   is uncorrelated with   , <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i>   When,   . Since the covariance of explanatory variable and error term is negative, OLS estimator <i>ß</i><sub>1</sub> will have a downward effect. and    <div class=answer> (i). When   is plugged into   <i> </i> <i>   </i>   Where,   Given that   is uncorrelated with   and   ,   is uncorrelated with   . Since   is uncorrelated with   , <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i>   When,   . Since the covariance of explanatory variable and error term is negative, OLS estimator <i>ß</i><sub>1</sub> will have a downward effect. ,    <div class=answer> (i). When   is plugged into   <i> </i> <i>   </i>   Where,   Given that   is uncorrelated with   and   ,   is uncorrelated with   . Since   is uncorrelated with   , <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i>   When,   . Since the covariance of explanatory variable and error term is negative, OLS estimator <i>ß</i><sub>1</sub> will have a downward effect. is uncorrelated with    <div class=answer> (i). When   is plugged into   <i> </i> <i>   </i>   Where,   Given that   is uncorrelated with   and   ,   is uncorrelated with   . Since   is uncorrelated with   , <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i>   When,   . Since the covariance of explanatory variable and error term is negative, OLS estimator <i>ß</i><sub>1</sub> will have a downward effect. . Since    <div class=answer> (i). When   is plugged into   <i> </i> <i>   </i>   Where,   Given that   is uncorrelated with   and   ,   is uncorrelated with   . Since   is uncorrelated with   , <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i>   When,   . Since the covariance of explanatory variable and error term is negative, OLS estimator <i>ß</i><sub>1</sub> will have a downward effect. is uncorrelated with    <div class=answer> (i). When   is plugged into   <i> </i> <i>   </i>   Where,   Given that   is uncorrelated with   and   ,   is uncorrelated with   . Since   is uncorrelated with   , <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i>   When,   . Since the covariance of explanatory variable and error term is negative, OLS estimator <i>ß</i><sub>1</sub> will have a downward effect. ,

    <div class=answer> (i). When   is plugged into   <i> </i> <i>   </i>   Where,   Given that   is uncorrelated with   and   ,   is uncorrelated with   . Since   is uncorrelated with   , <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i>   When,   . Since the covariance of explanatory variable and error term is negative, OLS estimator <i>ß</i><sub>1</sub> will have a downward effect.

    <div class=answer> (i). When   is plugged into   <i> </i> <i>   </i>   Where,   Given that   is uncorrelated with   and   ,   is uncorrelated with   . Since   is uncorrelated with   , <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i>   When,   . Since the covariance of explanatory variable and error term is negative, OLS estimator <i>ß</i><sub>1</sub> will have a downward effect.

    <div class=answer> (i). When   is plugged into   <i> </i> <i>   </i>   Where,   Given that   is uncorrelated with   and   ,   is uncorrelated with   . Since   is uncorrelated with   , <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i>   When,   . Since the covariance of explanatory variable and error term is negative, OLS estimator <i>ß</i><sub>1</sub> will have a downward effect.

    <div class=answer> (i). When   is plugged into   <i> </i> <i>   </i>   Where,   Given that   is uncorrelated with   and   ,   is uncorrelated with   . Since   is uncorrelated with   , <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i>   When,   . Since the covariance of explanatory variable and error term is negative, OLS estimator <i>ß</i><sub>1</sub> will have a downward effect.

When,     <div class=answer> (i). When   is plugged into   <i> </i> <i>   </i>   Where,   Given that   is uncorrelated with   and   ,   is uncorrelated with   . Since   is uncorrelated with   , <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i> <i> </i> <i>   </i>   When,   . Since the covariance of explanatory variable and error term is negative, OLS estimator <i>ß</i><sub>1</sub> will have a downward effect. .

Since the covariance of explanatory variable and error term is negative, OLS estimator ß1 will have a downward effect.


Step 2 of 4


Step 3 of 4


Step 4 of 4

close menu
Introductory Econometrics: A Modern Approach 6th Edition by Jeffrey M Wooldridge
cross icon