The chapter looks toward the future with optimism in regard to combining strong democratic constitutionalism with strong public administration. How convincing do you find the predictions made? Why? Can you develop a convincing counter argument? How do the changes in government and in the public in response to the events of September 11, 2001, reinforce or detract from the optimism of the predictions in this chapter?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer is The predictions made in the chapter about combining strong democratic constitutionalism with strong public administration are convincing to a certain extent. The idea of having a robust democratic system and an efficient public administration working in tandem is certainly appealing and has the potential to bring about positive change. However, the reality of implementing such a system is much more complex.

One counter argument is that strong democratic constitutionalism and strong public administration may not always align perfectly. In practice, there can be conflicts between the two, such as when the needs of the public clash with the limitations of the constitution or when bureaucratic red tape hinders the efficiency of public administration. Additionally, the nature of politics and power dynamics within a government can also complicate the seamless integration of these two ideals.

The events of September 11, 2001, and the subsequent changes in government and public response do both reinforce and detract from the optimism of the predictions in this chapter. On one hand, the need for a strong, capable public administration to respond to national security threats was made clear in the aftermath of the attacks. This reinforces the importance of having a well-functioning public administration. On the other hand, the government's response to 9/11 also raised concerns about the potential erosion of civil liberties in the name of national security, which could be seen as a setback for strong democratic constitutionalism.

In conclusion, while the predictions in the chapter are optimistic and appealing, the reality of implementing such a system is more nuanced. The events of 9/11 both reinforce and detract from this optimism, highlighting the complexity of balancing strong democratic constitutionalism with strong public administration.

The Chapter Looks Toward the Future with Optimism in Regard