A surgeon knowing fully well that except a miracle, nothing can save X, who is ailing from a disease. In good faith, if the surgeon operated on X, but a consequence of that operation X died, then which one of the following would be correct?
A)A is held guilty of murder for knowing will that X will not survive
B)A is guilty of murder because the death is the direct consequence of the operation.
C)A is not guilty because he has acted in good faith although knowing fully will that X will die.
D)The matter being subjective, no specific decision can be given.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The surgeon is not guilty of murder because they acted in good faith to try and save the patient, despite knowing the low chances of survival. This demonstrates an intention to help, not harm.

A Surgeon Knowing Fully Well That Except a Miracle, Nothing