Which, if any, of the following factors determines whether a paternalistic decision in medicine illustrates soft, as opposed to hard, paternalism?
A) That the benefits of a treatment compensate its burden for the patient
B) That the patient has or lacks mental competency
C) That the patient receives what she deserves
D) None of the above

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Whether a paternalistic decision in medicine illustrates soft or hard paternalism depends on whether the patient has mental competency. Soft paternalism refers to instances where the patient lacks mental competency and is unable to make decisions in their own best interest, while hard paternalism involves overriding a patient's autonomous decision, even if they are mentally competent. Factors such as the benefits and burden of treatment, or whether the patient deserves certain treatment, do not determine whether a paternalistic decision is soft or hard.

Which, If Any, of the Following Factors Determines Whether a Paternalistic