A problem noted by Beauchamp and Childress with the method of reflective equilibrium is:
A) Nonexperts cannot practice this method of moral reasoning.
B) There is too much contradiction in the ethics literature when different thinkers who have explicitly used this method seem to come up with different claims.
C) The objectives of even a weak wide reflective equilibrium may be unattainable ideals of comprehensiveness and coherence.
D) Reflective equilibrium is not an appropriate method for reasoning about particular policies.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The method of reflective equilibrium aims for a balance between our moral intuitions and principles, seeking coherence and comprehensiveness. Beauchamp and Childress critique that achieving even a weak wide reflective equilibrium may present unattainable ideals, given the complexity and diversity of moral considerations.

A Problem Noted by Beauchamp and Childress with the Method