Which of the following does Dutton cite as evidence that aesthetic judgment is evolutionarily advantageous?
A) The fact that pretend play occurs among children of all cultures at around 18-24 months.
B) The similarity of the notions of truth and beauty, and the fact that truth is evolutionary advantageous.
C) The near universal fascination humans have with fiction
D) All of the above

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Dennis Dutton, a philosopher of art, has argued that aesthetic judgment is an evolutionary trait that has been advantageous for human beings. He cites several pieces of evidence to support this claim:
A) The fact that pretend play occurs among children of all cultures at around 18-24 months. Pretend play is seen as a way for children to practice and develop cognitive and social skills, which are important for survival and reproduction. It involves imagination and an appreciation for the aesthetic elements of the play scenario, which can be seen as an early form of aesthetic judgment.
B) The similarity of the notions of truth and beauty, and the fact that truth is evolutionarily advantageous. Dutton suggests that our appreciation for beauty is linked to our search for truth, which has clear survival benefits. The ability to discern truth helps us make accurate judgments about the world, which can lead to better decision-making. Similarly, an appreciation for beauty can guide us towards choices that have positive outcomes, such as selecting healthy mates or fertile environments.
C) The near universal fascination humans have with fiction. Our interest in stories, narratives, and fiction allows us to explore hypothetical scenarios and learn from them without having to experience them directly. This can help us prepare for real-life situations and empathize with others, which are both beneficial for social cohesion and individual survival.
Dutton's argument is that these aspects of human behavior are not just cultural byproducts but have deep evolutionary roots that have helped humans to survive and thrive. By appreciating beauty, engaging in imaginative play, and being drawn to stories, our ancestors may have developed cognitive and social advantages that were passed down through generations.

Which of the Following Does Dutton Cite as Evidence That